Challenging the blood donation ban on LGBTQ+ individuals in India

a medico-legal and public policy analysis

Autores

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.18316/redes.v13i1.11934

Palavras-chave:

Blood Donation, LGBTQ+, Gender Identity, Discrimination, Stigma

Resumo

This paper both historicizes and contextualizes the contemporary US Food and Drug Administration(FDA)  blood donation policy banning men who have sex with men and transgender individuals although in 2023 they have changed their old policies and made new recommendations where MSM and LGBTQ+ community can donate blood but coming to India we are still following the age-old policies. These policies found their roots in the 1980s at the outset of the HIV/AIDS crisis, when fear and misinformation coupled the disease first and foremost with homosexual men, leading to lasting stigmatization and discriminatory practices. Yet, with all the strides made in blood testing technology and a better understanding of the HIV transmission process, such archaic policies thrive not just in India but in several other countries also. The paper contributed to this area while summarizing the evolution of knowledge on HIV, the window period for HIV detection, and international blood donation guidelines and argued that the blanket ban is not only lacking in scientific basis but also constitutionally unsound and violated basic human rights. It discriminates against gay men in monogamous relationships wherein heterosexual men who have multiple sexual partners are given the chance to be blood donors. This paper wishes the Indian government to act on rational reasoning with scientific grounds regarding blood donation, and eligibility where there can be deferrals of 90 days for MSM and transgender persons. These policies, upon updating, shall massively add to the potential blood donor pool that would save thousands of lives. This could best be crowned by the replacement of stigma with science on the road to a safe, inclusive blood donation.

Biografia do Autor

Niteesh Kumar Upadhyay, Associate Professor Symbiosis Law School, Noida, and Research Fellow Tashkent State Law University, Uzbekistan.

Dr. Niteesh Kumar Upadhyay is an Associate Professor of Law at Symbiosis Law School, Noida, and a Research Fellow at Tashkent State Law University, Uzbekistan, with additional roles as a guest faculty at Romanian American University and an international research fellow at the University of Milan. He holds a doctorate from WB National University of Juridical Sciences, Kolkata, and has over 35 publications, with extensive international experience and numerous scholarships and grants. Recently, he was appointed to the Academic Friends Network of the UN Human Rights Council Advisory Committee.

Sangeeta Taak, Rajiv Gandhi National University of Law, Punjab and Research fellow Tashkent State Law University, Uzbekistan

Dr. Sangeeta Taak is Doctor of Law and an Assistant Professor of Law at Rajiv Gandhi National University of Law, Punjab, India. She is a Research Fellow at Central Asian Legal Research (CALR), Tashkent State University of Law (TSUL), at Tashkent, Uzbekistan.

Ardyllis Alves Soares, Centro Universitário de Brasília, Brasília, DF

Pós-Doutorando em Direito pelo Centro Universitário de Brasília. Doutor e Mestre em Direito pela Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul - UFRGS, com estágio doutoral na Justus-Liebig-Universität Gießen - Alemanha. Possui especialização em Direito Internacional Público e Privado e Direito da Integração pela Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul - UFRGS (2011) e em Direito Empresarial pelo Instituto Brasileiro de Mercado de Capitais - IBMEC/RJ (2006), além de Diplôme d'Université em Direito Francês e Europeu dos Contratos (Université de Savoie - França). Possui graduação em Direito pela Universidade de Fortaleza (2004). Atualmente é pesquisador dos grupos de pesquisa CNPq da UFRGS "Mercosul, Direito do Consumidor e Globalização" e "Direito Internacional da Concorrência", coordenados pelos professores Claudia Lima Marques e Augusto Jaeger Junior, respectivamente. Professor Convidado da Pós-graduação lato sensu da UFRGS, ESMP/CE, UNIFOR e Estácio/RJ. Parecerista de periódicos. Tem artigos e capítulos publicados. 

Pyali Chatterjee, ICFAI University, Raipur, Chattisgarh,India and Research Fellow at Tashkent State University of Law, Uzbekistan.

Dr.Pyali Chatterjee is Doctor of Law and an Assistant Professor at Faculty of Law, ICFAI University, Raipur, India. She is a Research Fellow at Central Asian Legal Research (CALR), Tashkent State University of Law (TSUL), at Tashkent, Uzbekistan.

Referências

AGNIHOTRI, Naveen; CHATURVEDI, Yatendra Mohan; AGNIHOTRI, Ajju.. Impact Analysis of the National Guidelines for Blood Donor Selection in India: A Single Center Study. Indian Journal of Hematology and Blood Transfusion, v. 35, n. 4, 2019. p. 726–730. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12288-019-01100-1.

ARMSTRONG, P.J. et al., A mixed methods investigation Of the relationship between blood donor policy, interest in donation, and willingness to donate among gay, bisexual, and other men who have sex with men in Ontario, Canada, BMC Public Health, v. 22, article 849, p. 1-13. 2022. Available on: https://bmcpublichealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12889-022-13229-2. Access on: 12th, August 2024. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-022-13229-2.

CHOWDHURY, Fateha; ESTCOURT, Lise; MURPHY, Michael F..Mitigating the impact of blood shortages in England. British Journal of Haematology, v. 204, n, 5, 2024. p. 1660-1671. Available on: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/bjh.19344. Access on: 12th, August 2024. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/bjh.19344

CHOUDHURY, Nabajyoti; MATHUR, Ankit; SIBINGA, Cees Th Smit. COVID-19 Pandemic – blood supply challenges and approaches in AATM member countries. ISBT Science Series, v. 15, n. 4, 2020. Available on: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/voxs.12578. Access on: 12th, August 2024. DOI: 10.1111/voxs.12578.

CULHANE, John G. Bad Science, Worse Policy: The Exclusion of Gay Males from Donor Pools. Saint Louis University Public Law Review, v. 24, n.1, 2005. p. 129-148. Available on: https://scholarship.law.slu.edu/plr/vol24/iss1/10. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

DEHAAN, Elliot et al.. PEP to Prevent HIV Infection, 2022. Available on: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK562734/pdf/Bookshelf_NBK562734.pdf. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

FOOD AND DRUG ADMINISTRATION. FDA Finalizes Move to Recommend Individual Risk Assessment to Determine Eligibility for Blood Donations, FDA News Release. Available on: https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/fda-finalizes-move-recommend-individual-risk-assessment-determine-eligibility-blood-donations. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

HALKITIS, Perry. Discrimination and Homophobia Fuel the HIV Epidemic in Gay and Bisexual Men. Psychology & AIDS Exchange, 2012. p. 1, 4-11.

HOCHBERG, Francine A.. HIV/AIDS and blood donation policies: a comparative study of public health policies and individual rights norms. Duke Journal of Comparative & International Law, v. 12, n. 1, 2021. p. 231-280. Available on: https://scholarship.law.duke.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1194&context=djcil. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

KARAMITROS, Georgios; KITSOS, Nikolaos A.; KARAMITROU, Ioanna. The ban on blood donation on men who have sex with men: Time to rethink and reassess an outdated policy, Pan African Medical Journal, v. 27, article 99, 2017. Available on: https://panafrican-med-journal.com/content/article/27/99/full/. DOI:10.11604/pamj.2017.27.99.12891.

MIYASHITA, Ayako; GATES, Gary J.. UPDATE: Effects of Lifting Blood Donation Bans on Men who Have Sex with Men, The Williams Institute, 2017. Available on: https://williamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/wp-content/uploads/Blood-Donation-Ban-MSM-Sep-2014.pdf. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

PRINTZ, Heather. Some MSM Blood Donors Move from a Lifetime Deferral to a One Year Ban “Finally” or “Not Good Enough”? Journal of Health Care Law and Policy, v.21, n. 1, 2018. p. 71-114. Available on: https://digitalcommons.law.umaryland.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1359&context=jhclp. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

THAKUR, Sanjay K.; SINHA, Anil K.; NEGI, Dinesh K.; SINGH, Sompal, Effect of COVID-19 pandemic on blood transfusion service: an experience from a regional blood transfusion center. Blood science, v. 5, n. 3, 2023. p. 209-217. Available on: https://journals.lww.com/bls/fulltext/2023/07000/effect_of_covid_19_pandemic_on_blood_transfusion.8.aspx. DOI: 10.1097/BS9.0000000000000161. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

UNAIDS. Prevention gap report. 2016. Available on: https://www.unaids.org/en/resources/documents/2016/prevention-gap. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

WAINBERG, Mark A. et al, Reconsidering the lifetime deferral of blood donation by men who have sex with men, Canadian Medical Association Journal, v. 182, n. 12, 2010. p. 1321–1324. Available on:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2934798/. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

WILLIAMS, Cole; QUARTETTI, Maelle; ROCHA, Cindy; HARRIS, Skylar. Request for Revision of MSM Blood Donation Deferment Policy, 2022. Available on: https://www.fda.gov/media/163742/download. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION. Blood Products: Blood Donation. Available on: https://www.who.int/news-room/questions-and-answers/item/blood-products-why-should-i-donate-blood. Access on: 12nd, August 2024.

WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION. HIV and AIDS. Available on: https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/hiv-aids. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

ZUCOLOTO, Miriane Lucindo et all. Blood donation deferral policies among men who have sex with men in Brazil. Hematology, transfusion and cell therapy, v. 41, n. 2, 2019. p. 164-168. Available on: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6517649/. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

Other references

(2018) 10 SCC 1

A Timeline of HIV and AIDS, Available on: https://www.hiv.gov/hiv-basics/overview/history/hiv-and-aids-timeline . Access on: 12th, August 2024.

AIDSMap. What is the window period for HIV testing?, 2021. Availble on: https://www.aidsmap.com/about-hiv/what-window-period-hiv-testing. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

Argentina Lifts Ban on Gay Men Giving Blood. Time. 2015. Available on:

https://time.com/4038742/argentina-gay-blood-donation/ . Access on: 12th, August 2024.

CDC. Getting Tested for HIV. 2024. Available on:

https://www.cdc.gov/hiv/testing/?CDC_AAref_Val=https://www.cdc.gov/hiv/basics/hiv-testing/hiv-window-period.html. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

Centre cites scientific proof for refusing blood donation from trans, gay and sex workers.

Deccan Herald. Available on:

https://www.deccanherald.com/india/centre-cites-scientific-proof-for-refusing-blood-donation-from-trans-gay-and-sex-workers-1199259.html. Access on: 12nd, August 2024.

DR. SAFE HANDS. 4th Generation HIV test Accuracy | How To Get Tested For HIV/AIDS. 2024. Available on: https://drsafehands.com/topic/4th-gen-test-accuracy-how-to-get-tested-for-aids-faq. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

FDA Finalizes Move to Recommend Individual Risk Assessment to Determine Eligibility for Blood Donations. Available on: https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/fda-finalizes-move-recommend-individual-risk-assessment-determine-eligibility-blood-donations. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

FDA relaxes blood donation rules for gay and bisexual men: What are the new changes and why they have been introduced. The Indian Express. 2023. Available on: https://indianexpress.com/article/explained/explained-global/fda-relaxes-blood-donation-rules-for-gay-and-bisexual-men-what-are-the-new-changes-and-why-they-have-been-introduced-8605879/ . Access on: 12th, August 2024.

Full content of the decision may be found at: https://jurisprudencia.stf.jus.br/pages/search?classeNumeroIncidente=%22ADI%205543%22&base=acordaos&sinonimo=true&plural=true&page=1&pageSize=10&sort=_score&sortBy=desc&isAdvanced=true. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

Health Ministry backs 2017 guidelines that exclude transgender persons, MSM, female sex workers from donating blood. The Hindu Bureau. Available on: https://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/health/health-ministry-supports-2017-guidelines-that-exclude-transgender-persons-msm-and-female-sex-workers-from-donating-blood/article66607022.ece. Access on: 12nd, August 2024.

I-BASE. What is the window period for an HIV test? Available on: https://i-base.info/guides/testing/what-is-the-window-period. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

I-BASE. HIV test accuracy, results and further testing. Available on: https://i-base.info/guides/testing/test-accuracy-results-and-further-testing. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

India’s government opposes blood donations by LGBT+ community by citing ‘scientific evidence’. Independent. 2023. Available on: https://www.independent.co.uk/asia/india/india-transgender-lgbt-blood-donation-b2301274.html. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

Landmark change to blood donation eligibility rules on today’s World Blood Donor Day. Give blood. 2021. Available on: https://www.blood.co.uk/news-and-campaigns/news-and-statements/landmark-change-to-blood-donation-eligibility-rules-on-today-s-world-blood-donor-day/. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

NALSA v. Union of India, (2014) 5SCC 438

National Technical Guidelines for Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis. Available on: https://naco.gov.in/sites/default/files/National_Technical_Guidelines_(Web).pdf. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

Thangjam Santa Singh v. Union of India, Writ Petition, 2021. Available on: https://www.scobserver.in/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/PIL_Blood_Donation1.pdf. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

The Supreme Court in NALSA v. Union of India 2014 held that “discrimination on the ground of sex under Articles 15 and 16 of the constitution is a breach of fundamental rights of a person.

They ensure blood banks always have supply. The Times of India. Available on: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/bengaluru/they-ensure-blood-banks-always-have-supply/articleshow/103115435.cms. Access on: 12nd, August 2024.

Trans and gay people, women sex workers can’t donate blood: What the Centre said in SC. The Indian Express. 2023. Available on: https://indianexpress.com/article/explained/explained-law/trans-gays-female-sex-workers-blood-donation-8494145/. Access on: 12th, August 2024.

Origin of HIV and AIDS. (n.d.). Be In the KNOW. Available on: https://www.avert.org/professionals/history-hivaids/overview#:~:text=It%20is%20widely%20believed%20that,with%20HIV%20or%20developed%20AIDS

Parliamentary question. Blood donations by sexually active gay men. 2024. Available on: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/E-9-2019-002845_EN.html

Which countries prohibit gay or bisexual men from donating blood?. The Economist. 2021. Available: https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2021/06/14/which-countries-prohibit-gay-or-bisexual-men-from-donating-blood.

Downloads

Publicado

2025-04-30

Edição

v. 13 n. 1 (2025)

Seção

Artigos

Licença

Copyright (c) 2025 Revista Eletrônica Direito e Sociedade - REDES

Creative Commons License

Este trabalho está licenciado sob uma licença Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

Autores que submetem seus manuscritos para serem publicados  na Revista REDES concordam com os seguintes termos:

  1. Os autores declaram ter ciência de que mantém os direitos autorais concedendo à REDES o direito à publicação.

  2. Os autores declaram ter ciência de que o trabalho submetido será licenciado sob a Licença Creative Commons atribuição não-comercial que permite o compartilhamento do artigo com reconhecimento da autoria e publicação nesta revista.

  3. Os autores declaram ter ciência que em virtude de os artigos publicados nesta revista tem acesso público e gratuito.

  4. Os autores declaram, sob as penas da lei, que o texto é inédito e original e que têm ciência de que identificada a existência de plágio, os autores plagiados serão informados – para querendo, tomarem as medidas legais nas esferas cível e criminal – e, os autores do plágio terão seu acesso à revista bloqueado.

  5. Os autores declaram que – em caso de coautoria – todos contribuíram significativamente para a pesquisa.

  6. Os autores obrigam-se a fornecer retratações e (ou) correções de erros em caso de eventual detecção.

  7. Os autores obrigam-se a não publicar o texto submetido a REDES em outra Revista eletrônica (ou não).

 

Licença Creative Commons
A Revista Eletrônica Direito e Sociedade - REDES - está licenciado com uma Licença Creative Commons Atribuição-NãoComercial 4.0 Internacional.
Baseado no trabalho disponível em http://revistas.unilasalle.edu.br/index.php/redes/about/submissions#copyrightNotice.
Podem estar disponíveis autorizações adicionais às concedidas no âmbito desta licença em http://creativecommons.org/.